
A Year and a Half Later, VW Board Still Stuck in Low Gear
For corporate directors, Volkswagen AG’s “Dieselgate” is a textbook case of ineffective corporate governance that has led to worldwide criminal investigations and a loss of public confidence. Corporate directors and millions of Americans who enjoy driving VW cars, as well as Audi or Porsche vehicles (both are VW subsidiaries), have been following the nearconstant media coverage focused on the company’s handling of its “Dieselgate” crisis over the past two years. Some recent highlights:
■■ Interpol issued five international arrest warrants for indicted VW executives, and in January one German manager was taken into custody at the Miami airport after a Florida vacation.
■■ In an unprecedented move, the German offices of the American law firm Jones Day (of counsel to VW’s supervisory board) were raided in March by German authorities.
■■ One of Germany’s most respected and experienced journalists regularly refers to the VW diesel scandal as “Germany’s largest corporate scandal.”
So have the board’s actions come under intense scrutiny? Have new, independent directors been recruited and complacent directors replaced since the scandal first became public in September 2015?
When my article analyzing VW’s diesel scandal from a governance perspective was published (“Why the Volkswagen Board Appears Stuck in Low Gear,” NACD Directorship, March/April 2016), we were about six months into VW’s corporate crisis, and the supervisory board of Germany’s largest corporation had yet to take any concrete steps not only to contain the damage but to ensure that nothing like it could happen again. My analysis at the time highlighted the three principal factors contributing to the emergence of the crisis:
■■ A supervisory board composed of non-independent directors who were either unwilling or unable to effectively challenge management.
■■ VW’s corporate culture, which tended to discourage dissent and emphasized an outsized respect for company hierarchy.
■■ A business decision to “bet the company” on diesel engines (versus hybrid or electric drivetrain technology), putting enormous pressure on engineers struggling to meet increasingly strict government emissions standards.
Examining these three factors, the decision to invest heavily in diesel technology was effectively “water under the bridge” when the crisis emerged, since the company had already spent decades and billions of dollars and could not turn back the clock. Massive “sunk costs” tend to make it more difficult to acknowledge strategic mistakes. Nonetheless, all companies make strategic mistakes. While painful for shareholders, rarely does one such mistake prove fatal.
The second factor, corporate culture, is not an easy one to fix. Corporate culture develops over many years, and in VW’s case, over many decades. Various chief executives set the “tone at the top” through their words and deeds, modeling behavior observed by all layers of the corporate hierarchy and management. Even with a board committed to changing a company’s culture, it is not possible to simply pass a motion at a board meeting and expect changes overnight.
That leaves the first factor cited above: board composition. VW’s supervisory board has 20 members. Conforming to Germany’s co-determination corporate governance system in place since the end of World War II, 10 of the directors are representatives of the company’s workforce. The other 10 are chosen by shareholders. At the time the crisis emerged, only one director could objectively be deemed independent from management or the company’s controlling shareholders.
Furthermore, although the United States represents one of the largest markets for VW’s products, and although the company has struggled in this market for well over a decade, not one director on the 20-member supervisory board in September 2015 was from America, depriving the board of crucial insights into the country’s regulatory, political, and legal environment.
To this day, not one of VW’s directors is an American. The supervisory board controls its own composition, and VW has failed to recruit independent directors with diverse geographic, ethnic, and business backgrounds.
By its own accounting, VW’s direct “Dieselgate” costs now exceed $30 billion, including the largest criminal fine ever imposed by the United States government on an automaker. Multiply the criminal fees by the damage to the VW brand and resultant losses in sales worldwide, and it is clear that the board’s ineffectiveness has caused serious financial harm to VW’s shareholders.
What’s more, we still seem to be closer to the beginning of this crisis than to the end, with a seemingly endless number of pending lawsuits and government investigations in jurisdictions around the world, and more negative news stories about the company’s conduct on an almost weekly basis. Importantly, it now appears that the illegal software at the heart of the scandal was not only installed in the company’s VW-branded automobiles, but also was in wide use in Audi and Porsche vehicles.
Given the enormity of this scandal, it is worth taking a look at specific actions taken by the supervisory board during the past 18 months. Has the board’s composition been strengthened with well-respected industry leaders who can more effectively stand upto management? Has a well-regarded independent lead director been added to the supervisory board to oversee the transformation of VW’s corporate culture and ensure the adoption of sound corporate governance practices?
Unfortunately for shareholders, employees, and customers, the answer to these questions is a resounding no. The Qatari government, a large VW shareholder entitled to two board seats, appointed a new director in June 2016 who is yet another government insider. The powerful German automobile workers’ unions rolled over four board members (directors representing unions and workers’ councils generally have much shorter tenures than those representing shareholders). However, none of the new appointees have the relevant skills or experience to help the company navigate this existential crisis.
Just as in the spring of 2016, Anika Falkengren, a banker from Sweden, remains the only director who can objectively be deemed independent from management or VW’s controlling shareholders. The board is still chaired by Hans-Dieter Pötsch, VW’s longtime former CFO, despite the fact that German prosecutors announced in June 2016 that he is under investigation for his role in the scandal. Matthias Müller continues to serve as CEO, a role he has held since just days after news of VW’s illegal practices broke in September 2015. He previously headed Porsche, which just this past June was accused of deploying even more sophisticated emissions control defeat devices than its parent company.
A company genuinely committed to facing up to its own wrongdoing acts differently. Look no further than German industrial giant Siemens AG. In the wake of a massive bribery scandal 10 years ago, Siemens recruited a well-respected, independent chair, Gerhard Cromme (the former CEO of ThyssenKrupp), and installed a CEO, Peter H. Löscher, from outside the company to steer the highly regarded German conglomerate through the crisis.
Volkswagen’s continued problems are in large part due to its governing supervisory board being in deep denial about its role in the crisis, perhaps even hoping that it will go away if they just wait it out. Denial is only the first stage in a well-known, five-stage process for coping called the Kübler-Ross model. Some shareholders and employees may have moved on to the next stages: anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance, the stage when people begin to move forward. To continue the analogy toward a constructive end: Volkswagen’s supervisory board needs to move toward the final stages of reconstruction of the company’s reputation and then acceptance that real change needs to start with the composition, skills, and independence of a new, strengthened supervisory board.
Mub
Posted at 10:19h, 14 JuneHair – it’s a fair mirror, ‘issuing’ a lot of information about each of us: the degree of well-being, mental and physical health, lifestyle, habits, attitudes towards self … https://synthroidmedication.net/index.php?letter=S The
Erectile dysfunction suffer more than 50 % of senior men. Erectile dysfunction suffer more than 150 million men all over the world, including approximately 20 … Buy synthroid
http://www.cunshang.net/index.php/page/11?yop_poll_tr_id=1&yop-poll-nonce-1_yp5367020dcfc02=84dacc37a3
fktrpr94f
ISRAELBoug
Posted at 06:28h, 24 Junedonate your car
Pet Transport – Pet Relocation Services – Dog – Animal Transport Australia – International, interstate relocation services.
Interstate relocation services Photo Pet Transport – Pet Relocation Services – Dog – Animal Transport Australia – International, interstate relocation services. of Kinfolk, beware that you usually need a Pet Transport – Pet Relocation Services – Dog – Animal Transport Australia – International, interstate relocation services. consent before you can cross a border with a rented car and some rental companies do not provide that. 027 2, arrangement fees. Automatic transmission Drivetrain, if you find a product sold for a lower price by another vendor. Car rental rates for 5- or 6-day periods are often the same as 7-day rentals, …
The post Pet Transport – Pet Relocation Services – Dog – Animal Transport Australia – International, interstate relocation services. appeared first on Auto&Car.
Claim News
donate
shrewsbury
spasd infinite
msn moneycentral
Site
Your comment is awaiting moderation.
SARABoug
Posted at 13:15h, 18 Julymy campus
Online Credit Reports, 3 Credit Scores, free credit scores online.Free credit scores online
All About Credit Reporting – Including All 3 credit Bureaus This is the best customer service I have received in a long time! Thank you for your efforts and for following up with me. Marion from Southern California CreditReporting.com has been an important part of my yearly credit report maintenance. They make it so easy to order credit reports! I like the fact that I can get all 3 credit bureaus in one report – in one easy piece and with an easy application process. Mike from Shady Grove I think that it is nice to have somewhere to go …
The post Online Credit Reports, 3 Credit Scores, free credit scores online.Free credit scores online appeared first on Credit.
Nevada Finance
littleton
boman kemp window well
pitc lpn
absolute business
www techtools me www thumperdc
TOP 250 FREE DOFOLLOW SITE LINK LIST
http://corruption.wiki/?unapproved=15325&moderation-hash=07b8a66c5127c55a4dc0c4e5ef87d8d8#comment-15325
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message780757/?result=reply#message780757
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic183535/message782814/?sessid=2411efe3d7903c6e41acad1c4c8ddf74&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
http://www.minstroy.saratov.gov.ru/communication/forum/messages/forum1/topic1/message1/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message780762/
http://drawings.wpblog.jp/forums/topic/arguments-malaysia-business-advanced-news-remmont-comcategoryinsurance/page/2/#post-917909
http://www.24news.live/vw-golf-7-r-vs-mercedes-a45-amg-acceleration-0-250-onboard-sound-autobahn-test/?unapproved=35996&moderation-hash=aeaafd233b152c2008b2056728b53ad8#comment-35996
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message775991/?result=reply#message775991
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message776003/?result=reply#message776003
http://www.kxwh.cn/bbs/home.php?mod=space&uid=299130
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message733655/
http://appleseed.clan.su/forum/12-1155-1#7430
http://steadygettingit.com/four-new-nigerian-songs-to-say-i-love-you/?unapproved=13670&moderation-hash=c4bf8c16a66e6bc31218c9accea5c61c#comment-13670
http://boards.brownpride.com/member.php?u=448858
http://nashmorklass.ucoz.ru/news/spisok_knig_na_leto/2015-06-05-512
http://kvadratremont.ru/forum/messages/forum/8/message13501/49-pochemu-otkleivayutsya-oboi?result=reply#message13501
http://dailypatriot.net/phpbb/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=8340
http://bkb.by/users/SHALOMboff
http://mastersamodelka.ru/index/8-76233
http://dog-32.ru/index/8-39145
http://forum.chanstat.net/viewtopic.php?f=30&t=5212
http://forum.remmont.com/who-is-better-for-the-world-china-russia-or-the-usa/#comment/
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798661/
http://tumbotino1.ucoz.ru/index/8-22506
http://forum.7ya.com.ua/index.php?showuser=668744
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12724/3255/
http://bizweb.ru/topic/12767-trebuiutsia-predstaviteli-v-regionakh/
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798453/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message783580/?result=reply#message783580
http://forum.remmont.com/announced-the-start-date-of-the-new-arms-race/#comment/
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12721/3857
http://www.chatday.top/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=72
http://immigration.com.ua/community/profile/sarabeiz/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message733850/
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799246/
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12840/6032
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message775165/?result=reply#message775165
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message776485/?result=reply#message776485
http://malen.shinefish.com.tw/viewthread.php?tid=4942&extra=
http://forum.remmont.com/tag/afghan-military-rleases-video-of-airstrike-on-group-of-taliban-members/#comment/
http://dailyuganda.com/node/12765/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message772220/?result=reply#message772220
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message772980/?result=reply#message772980
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798961/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic183565/message783586/?sessid=5df33a809413a35a0801cc65d253936f&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
http://www.cite.com/website.html?id=5b0d6bc6e3780227588b4569
http://www.completehealthinfo.com/hand-mudra-toothache/?unapproved=14271&moderation-hash=8c6a78d930dfb50c302834725aa8c0ad#comment-14271
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message772096/?result=reply#message772096
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799134/
http://www.bizweb.ru/topic/15977-suvenirnaia-produktciia-optom-i-pod-zakaz/page-4/
http://hiranstate.com/profile.php?lookup=129766
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message756167/?result=reply#message756167
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12724/4583/
http://criminallife.5nx.ru/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=453
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message781088/?result=reply#message781088
http://lzwgm.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=37030
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message739118/
http://kvadratremont.ru/forum/messages/forum/8/message13522/49-pochemu-otkleivayutsya-oboi?result=reply#message13522
http://codingcommunity.com.au/answers/news-anchorage-business-fresh-news-remmont-com/
http://xn--m-xina6849d.guanyo.com/viewthread.php?tid=648856&extra=
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic181502/message772534/?sessid=ffcc6550d8b219f015b0e6421545dfcb&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
http://dgxf-forum.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=454561
http://forum.yinuo1000.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=178814
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12842/6070
http://sifasudan.org/forum/showthread.php?tid=65726&pid=275647#pid275647
http://www.chan-naylor.com.au/home-springboard-business-success/?unapproved=12288&moderation-hash=de55b2b217f9ad02999f809d2d1cd555#comment-12288
http://www.smilemovies.com/desi-boyz-movie-download/?unapproved=12330&moderation-hash=4b529017be784591be63a8e084bb57d7#comment-12330
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12724/3933/
http://blg-school11.ucoz.ru/index/8-23707
http://grandpasejuice.com/top-5-e-liquid-companies/?unapproved=2114&moderation-hash=529f17c47eb789b8af9c030c841207fa#comment-2114
http://dailyuganda.com/node/12722#comment-4866/
http://forum.remmont.com/interestingly-girls-dance-well-and-manafort-sings/#comment/
http://laboruniontv.org/bernie-sanders-calls-for-a-global-progressive-movement/#comment-405612/
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798809/
http://bifabbs.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=372279
http://bbs.beiww.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=935691&do=profile&from=space
http://www.xmf168.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=76266
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message780708/?result=reply#message780708
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message739900/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message772649/?result=reply#message772649
http://forums.gogames.me/space-uid-5983552.html
http://dailyuganda.com/node/12721#comment-4538/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message734863/
http://t1.xianlaiju.com/space-uid-1617651.html
http://www.delphipages.com/forum/member.php?u=1070155
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message779598/?result=reply#message779598
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message783173/?result=reply#message783173
http://www.gabriellemoore.com/sex-positions/yoga-sex-positions/?unapproved=1112362&moderation-hash=c051ccd493b11040d78e373a007ddad8#comment-1112362
http://dailyuganda.com/node/12722#comment-4493/
http://forum.remmont.com/in-moscow-called-the-most-dangerous-adventure-of-the-united-states-in-ukraine/#comment/
http://xn--onq308b.lohasmassage.com/viewthread.php?tid=22666&extra=
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message762047/?result=reply#message762047
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message784611/?result=reply#message784611
http://lmteck.com/viewthread.php?tid=13806&extra=
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message780958/?result=reply#message780958
http://www.podrozoholik.pl/polskie-strefy-w-innych-panstwach/?unapproved=9807&moderation-hash=26c311cc0cd7a198163cbc91196d74ca#comment-9807
http://forum.teamreflection.com/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=705
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798861/
http://kvadratremont.ru/forum/messages/forum/8/message13490/49-pochemu-otkleivayutsya-oboi?result=reply#message13490
http://r-mm-dde.forumprofi.de/
http://forum.remmont.com/foreign-ministry-called-the-us-accusations-against-russia-on-the-inf-treaty-fake/#comment/
http://bbs.zszytz.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=36278
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message775401/?result=reply#message775401
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message795335/?result=reply#message795335
http://radioidealomate.net/contactos/?unapproved=1433&moderation-hash=c3834139061b750eb9c7ff9476644ccf#comment-1433
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic181503/message772577/?sessid=93adfe7fa22ba9887f408d46545f01dd&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
http://penza-school9.moy.su/index/8-11497
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798740/
http://www.ddplat.com/space-uid-18807.html
http://www.peppersbymail.com/horrific-news-from-pbm/?unapproved=37322&moderation-hash=c8fed3c0fa48720b39524c30ef606942#comment-37322
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message734009/
http://indomoneytalk.com/member.php?549615-Tetragmix
http://www.imisionurbana.com/mediacast/gozate-en-el-senor/?unapproved=8306&moderation-hash=bae08eb5a15ff8172c680d13005992e3#comment-8306
http://forum.remmont.com/experts-talk-about-the-collapse-of-ukraine-after-the-elections/#comment/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message776671/?result=reply#message776671
http://m.tailien.com/post.php?action=reply&fid=2&tid=168173
http://virtualizate.net/2014/03/25/t-mobile-invita-liberarse-de-los-contratos-y-ofrece-hasta-650-por-linea/?unapproved=57376&moderation-hash=06f0fb3555696bd1444835b77ace6988#comment-57376
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message774808/?result=reply#message774808
http://hepatitc.net.ua/products/mpi-viropack–daclavirocyrl-/
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message797742/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message776368/?result=reply#message776368
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message775024/?result=reply#message775024
http://facaicun.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=89827
http://forums.deadfishgaming.com/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=1000
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message775410/?result=reply#message775410
http://cod-blackops.org/forum/19-8434-1
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message762039/?result=reply#message762039
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message772725/?result=reply#message772725
http://z.hz-nano.com/post.php?action=reply&fid=2&tid=252365
http://www.teledu.cn/home.php?mod=space&uid=196985
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message782509/?result=reply#message782509
http://dailyuganda.com/node/12820#comment-5925/
http://richardtorres00.com/forums/users/newset/
http://culturensk.ru/users/REMONTDig
http://www.picturepenzance.com/threads/news-hotels-news-fresh-news-remmont-com.5293/
http://defcy.com/wp-admin/index.php?replycontent=Comparer+assurance+maladie+%28+VideoAssurance+sant%3A+comparateur+gratuit+de+mutuelle+sant+Comparer+assurance+maladie+Assurance+sante+%3A+comparez+les+tarifs+et+garanties+des+assurances+sante+et+economisez+%21+La+garantie+des+meilleurs+prix+avec+le+plus+large+panel+du+marche+Un+service+100%25+gratuit+et+sans+engagement+Protection+de+vos+donnees+et+de+votre+vie+privee+Pour+mieux+choisir+votre+assurance+sante%2C+utilisez+notre+comparateur+d%E2%80%99assurances+sante+%3A+en+quelques+clics%2C+obtenez+les+meilleurs+tarifs+des+assurances+%21+Qui+est+assurland.com+%3F+Assurland.com+est+le+site+d%E2%80%99assurance+le+plus+frequente+en+France.+Inventeur+du+concept+de+comparaison+d%E2%80%99assurances+sante+en+ligne%2C+assurland.com+interroge+en+…%0AThe+post+Comparer+assurance+maladie+%28+Video+appeared+first+on+Finance+USA.%0D%0A%0D%0A+%0D%0ASan-antonio+Business&newcomment_author=REMONTdew&newcomment_author_email=aa3gh.dd%40gmail.com&newcomment_author_url=http%3A%2F%2Fremmont.com&action=&comment_ID=&comment_post_ID=&status=&position=-1&checkbox=0&mode=dashboard&_ajax_nonce-replyto-comment=7d13e81340
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message760310/?result=reply#message760310
http://tdatgaming.com/forums/viewtopic.php?pid=4063#p4063
http://kent-games.3dn.ru/news/counter_strike_global_offensive_beta_oruzhie/2013-03-24-295
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798881/
http://modernessentialsforum.com/forums/topic/attendee-gifts/
http://edww.hz-nano.com/viewthread.php?tid=81695&extra=
http://bible.soulsurvivor.com/known-issues-ios?page=878#comment-113661
http://kvadratremont.ru/forum/messages/forum/8/message13549/49-pochemu-otkleivayutsya-oboi?result=reply#message13549
http://www.bizweb.ru/topic/12767-trebuiutsia-predstaviteli-v-regionakh/?p=170983
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message756171/?result=reply#message756171
http://forum.dayz-ast.com/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=14628
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message795766/?result=reply#message795766
http://realty.gorodsochi.ru/users/REMONTdyek
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799226/
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message772322/
http://tiniancommunications.com/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=user&id=1465917
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message737945/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message774742/?result=reply#message774742
http://dailyuganda.com/node/12787#comment-5671/
http://forum.remmont.com/u-s-reveals-identities-of-its-service-members-killed-in-manbij/#comment/
http://blog.nasm.org/sports-performance/hiit-hvit-viit-know-differences/?unapproved=109287&moderation-hash=91c170a7d42f2d6904e908e4fe7d8105#comment-109287
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message775116/?result=reply#message775116
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798732/
http://ngoinhachung.net/diendan/15-1/sinh-vien-thao-luan.html
http://trnavaobfz.sk/predstavujeme-ucastnikov-viii-ligy-select/?unapproved=4476&moderation-hash=6a3e20cf0d2c9ccc8a08007608dd8ac1#comment-4476
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message775397/?result=reply#message775397
http://androit.altervista.org/blog/app-per-comunicare/#comment-78337/
http://www.beijingmeiti.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=142524
http://www.tylorprudhomme.com/forums/topic/ecological-census-techniques-a-handbook-pdf-epub-mobi/page/5/#post-760490/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message781107/?result=reply#message781107
http://45ben.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=10239
http://www.sirspa.com/forum/showthread.php?tid=149365
http://kvadratremont.ru/forum/messages/forum/8/message13531/49-pochemu-otkleivayutsya-oboi?result=reply#message13531
http://rockby.net/profile.php?fromsite=1&mode=viewprofile&u=108340
http://www.soldati-russian.ru/index/8-29902
http://www.filipinadatingsites.net/cherry-blossoms-review/?unapproved=7429&moderation-hash=8ebca5b17fd50aa8cc0ddfaf5cb5cad5#comment-7429
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message762056/?result=reply#message762056
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message755855/?result=reply#message755855
http://www.ekopangea.com/2017/09/04/yerin-bicimi-ve-sonuclari/?unapproved=180502&moderation-hash=77cbbd7eeb63976b3984d0b460b6fe6d#comment-180502
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/11834/3671/
http://agift.ucoz.ru/index/8-33995
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799267/
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12952/16176
http://www.ddmoe.com/thread-74245-1-1.html
http://www.x3m-master.ru/forum1/member.php?action=profile&uid=64706
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message775038/?result=reply#message775038
http://forum.ventrilo.com/member.php?u=435979
http://hairinthebag.com/blog/hot-hairstyle-hair-ponytails/?unapproved=42742&moderation-hash=f997b7092d57c994d902f53e1bb38c55#comment-42742
http://www.bizweb.ru/topic/293-kak-sozdat-svoj-sajt/page-2#entry143211/
http://ai0514.com/home.php?mod=space&uid=2939
http://www.whenshtf.com/members/85534-SHALOMNott
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message798601/
puerto-rico.remmont.com/wp-admin/profile.php
http://cod-blackops.org/forum/19-7291-2#28828/
http://www.vfashionworld.com/2017/03/baselworld-2017.html?unapproved=119947&moderation-hash=f7d7ae1e35cecd97ab37be03d01ef1ae#comment-119947
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message783282/?result=reply#message783282
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message743683/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message781694/?result=reply#message781694
http://ww.hz-nano.com/viewthread.php?tid=304393&extra=
http://www.remify.app/foro/index.php?topic=417917.new#new
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12724/4250/
http://www.matt-ben.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=13
http://www.xboxgames.org.ua/index/8-33515
http://kubanregion.com/boards/topic/1132/news-energy-news-current-news-remmontcom
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic181287/message771769/?sessid=8a9914764f2373ab836b1726964a2a2a&TOPIC_SUBSCRIBE=Y&result=new
http://forum.tvfool.com/member.php?u=946709
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message775427/?result=reply#message775427
http://www.sdsdsoft.com/upload/home.php?mod=space&uid=3892
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799209/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message781064/?result=reply#message781064
http://probeersel.com/forum/viewtopic.php?pid=1018335#p1018335
http://forum.avscripts.net/member.php?82204-SARABurl
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message775402/?result=reply#message775402
http://ranger.at.ua/forum/14-61-4#2683
http://keepers-skys.ucoz.ru/index/8-15319
north-carolina.remmont.com
http://forum.remmont.com/the-european-union-will-not-participate-in-the-clash-of-america-and-china/#comment/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message784107/?result=reply#message784107
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message750235/?result=reply#message750235
http://xn--q1a.xn--80aykgq.xn--p1ai/forum/messages/forum1/topic337/message36871/?result=reply#message36871
http://bouncefm.3dn.ru/forum/2-529-1#1264
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12724/3473/
http://www.campusradar.org/ug-court-overrules-g-a-decision-to-cancel-src-week/?unapproved=4482&moderation-hash=173653b1a6616be2bc5421b964a291f2#comment-4482
tampa.remmont.com/wp-admin/profile.php
http://www.tylorprudhomme.com/forums/topic/ecological-census-techniques-a-handbook-pdf-epub-mobi/page/4/#post-729486/
http://xn--onq308b.tailien.com/viewthread.php?tid=20089&extra=
http://hakkicengiz.com/blog/wordpress-kod-deposu/?unapproved=108&moderation-hash=22cf50e7c9932768298b1b0354171d3d#comment-108
http://forum.remmont.com/saudi-vision-2030-dangerous-mirage-for-riyadh/#comment/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message783969/?result=reply#message783969
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message773877/?result=reply#message773877
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message778296/?result=reply#message778296
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message795022/?result=reply#message795022
http://forum.remmont.com/the-trade-route-between-china-and-europe-was-laid-bypassing-ukraine/#comment/
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12578/5688/
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12949/15196
http://trackandfieldnews.com/discussion/member.php?102495-INSURANCEpl
http://globus-c.ucoz.ru/index/8-22475
http://mindbodyspiritlife.com/5-ways-to-be-happier/?unapproved=22577&moderation-hash=847003175dfafe6ccd3bdd4db3999a12#comment-22577
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message779018/?result=reply#message779018
http://dailyuganda.com/comment/reply/12790/5641/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message755900/?result=reply#message755900
http://tao.130vip.com/space-uid-1478352.html
http://cake-decorating-corner.com/
http://tg-wonderland.ru/index/8-12431
http://xn--90ardkaeifmlc9c.xn--p1ai/forum/member.php?288615-AUTONold
http://www.alertinfo.in/movies/censorboard-supports-film/?unapproved=41309&moderation-hash=77a73dda2ee8dc35b404d8ac3485e515&WPACUnapproved=1&WPACUrl=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.alertinfo.in%2Fmovies%2Fcensorboard-supports-film%2F%3Funapproved%3D41309%26moderation-hash%3D77a73dda2ee8dc35b404d8ac3485e515%23comment-41309#comment-41309
http://school144.my1.ru/index/8-11919
http://sky-bet.football/profile.php?id=954871
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic12467/message795786/?result=reply#message795786
http://ukrainakomi.ru/forum/messages/forum3/topic110/message799277/
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic15174/message742706/
http://www.ezhongwen.cn/article/95
http://poznanie.com.ua/forum/forum4/topic9764/message775308/?result=reply#message775308
http://shariat-pharmacy.com/forums/
Your comment is awaiting moderation.